People often ask a question: "What's the difference between
Osteopathy and...?" There is no straight-forward answer to this question. Traditionally Osteopathy
is distinguished by it's complex (holistic) approach to the
body which is taken as a unit. Also Osteopathy is known
for it's soft tissue work. The following are some comparisons with other hands-on
practicies:
Bone-setting
- an old folk method of "putting bones back into place".
It does not require any special education, as one
learns from experience with a master or from a family member. Because
of the lack of a science base, bone-setters are almost extinct these
days.
Chiropractic - appeared
at about the same time as
Osteopathy. More attention is put on joints manipulation ("clicking")
and less work with soft tissues. This makes the Chiropractic work
harder and sometimes uncomfortable for the patient, but good for stubborn stiff
joints.
Manipulative Physiotherapy
- especially
popular in Australia. Apart from manipulation it places greater emphasis on exercises and
stretching.
Manual
Therapy
- popular in Eastern Europe. It has appeared in medicine
as a "proper" scientific method of hands-on
treatment deriving it's base from several sources and lately it's own research.
The main defect is the short duration of study and a certain
"hastiness" of treatment. After doing 2 months of theory
and practice a doctor can become a manual therapist, while in
Osteopathy a doctor needs at least 1 year of studying and practical
training.
There is a variety of other hands-on practices apart from those
already mentioned: rolfing, different types of massage (classical,
connective tissue, deep soft tissue massages, shiatsu, aroma-therapy
and others), bio-enegry treatment and so on. All of them treat the
body but do not make a diagnosis.
It is worthwhile mentioning that individual experience and talent
play a great role in how the practitioner works. One can meet an
Osteopath who uses hard techniques or a chiropractor who uses
relatively gentle ones. A good reputation, as in ancient times,
remains the main criteria of whom to go to for treatment.
|